Apocryphal

About

Username
Apocryphal
Joined
Visits
11,883
Last Active
Roles
Member, Administrator, Moderator

Comments

  • BTW There’s a ‘companion volume’ to Strangers in Olondria’ called ‘The Winged Histories’. I don’t think it’s a sequel, but rather tells a different story in the same setting. There’s some small reference to the first book, but it stands quite alo…
  • Jacq’s cat = Schrödinger’s cat! It’s fate will be determined when Jacj comes home and opens the door.
  • @BarnerCobblewood Oh, that’s easy - you give your stave to an adept, along with 50 simoleons, and then walk backwards up a hill, drive forward down the hill, and row your luggage twice around the harbour… (a reference to The Gradual).
  • We need to have the early part to introduce Jevick and his relationship to his father. And to his mentor, Lunre, who comes back at then end (ghostlike) as a more pivotal character than we initially thought. The story structure is something like:…
  • If I was to pick the books again, based on reader reactions, I’d pick The Affirmation for the novel (much tighter around the idea and a more satisfying story), the The Dream Archipelago, and lastly The Islanders. I enjoyed the read - for me a 3.5…
  • Interesting catch re: Dante. Although I agree it's a love story in a sense, though it never feels like a romantic love story so much as a story of love that evolves through shared experience. It's a love story, but not a romance, if that makes sense.
  • @BarnerCobblewood What's "our present situation"? I agree with the mythic arc. Elsewhere, @RichardAbbott asked if it bothered us the Jevick shed his spice trader identity so soon. I would argue that was never his identity - is was rather …
  • You might think that maps and games go together, given how often gamers ogle and make a fuss about them. But I think it's that gamers just love evocative imaginary maps, rather than that 'they go' with games. Some games are hard to imagine without m…
  • My first impressions were rather of renaissance Italy and Constantinople. The novel definitely has a sense of place, and there's a lot of wonderful creative elements in the world building that I really enjoyed. What particularly caught my eye were a…
  • There are a lot of rich characters - some of the richest aren't even named, like the old woman who lies in the rug but seems to communicate some much with her eye. Here's another example: (Quote) Those are the ones I especially loved, but all the m…
  • I have a love-hate relationship with this book. I love the writing, and at almost any point you can find a wonderful turn of phrase. The prose is almost poetic (and oddly, the poetry is prosaic). I picked up several quotable passages on this read th…
  • I think it's mainly about how our memories, past experiences, and the people who raise us can shape us. It's also a love story, but here love in the greater sense, rather than personal love. Jevick goes from fearing his ghost to loving it over the c…
  • And unsurprisingly, that’s what most reviews seem to say LOL.
  • > @RichardAbbott said: > it is as though CP's main interest in writing shifts multiple times through a single novel. He did more or less say the book was about gradual change right at the very beginning. And he does like to take ‘concepts…
  • Christopher Priest didn’t say that. One of his characters did. And that character might be misinformed, biased, or have an incomplete picture, just like real people.
  • > "The only real record that existed of music was the original score, the black pen marks on the staves, but they were cryptic, had no sound, were written in code – they had no meaning without the human spirit that could break the code, inte…
  • I’m 50 pages in, now. It’s very descriptive and definitely has a sense of place. Loads of little details make it vivid. Doesn’t seem like a book you can skim without getting lost - I find I have to force myself to read with purpose to get the most f…
  • @clash_bowley Right… so the question remains as to whether this is one of those books or not. It’s definitely literary in intent. I don’t recall if the internal logic was sound. I do recall that it had a lot of words. :) and was somewhat rambly. …
  • As I mentioned elsewhere, I’ve been reading Binti by mistake. However, I’ll catch up on Stranger. Might need two weeks. I think Stanger is more a book for @RichardAbbott , @BarnerCobblewood , @WildCard , and me, than it is for @NeilNjae ( who has…
  • Oops. I’ve been reading Binti. However, I’ve read Stranger before. I’ll try to catch up… refresh my memory.
  • I’d actually be fine with playing low level functionaries trying to steer a state. I prefer low levels to big heroes. But I don’t see how playing this kind of game on Dune would be more satisfying than in Gormemghast, for example. But when I thin…
    in Dune Comment by Apocryphal October 2021
  • I honestly don’t think I’d try to game Dune. The politics are interesting, and especially the politics of scarcity, but I’m not good at running politics.
    in Dune Comment by Apocryphal October 2021
  • Here are a few more books I picked up this year. The four on the left came from Little Free Libraries. The Farley Mowat book, No Man's River, is a sort of companion to his famous (and infamous, because it's the book the earned the author a reputati…
  • It was Hellstrom's Hive - book #67 for us. You can find the list of the first 71 books pinned in the Nominations & Suggestions thread. I recently found a copy of another Herbert book in a little free library, called Direct Descent. I'll share a…
    in Dune Comment by Apocryphal October 2021
  • I mostly know Anthony from the Xanth series, which I enjoyed as a young teen. Not sure I still would. I’d happily read The Adjacent with you as a side project if you like. Not sure the others would be interested at this point.
  • I did read Ringworld once, but other that that am not wise to Niven. Was The Mote in Gods Eye a Niven and Pournell collab? Anne McCaffrey’s Deagonriders are famous, and we’re pretty big back in the early 80s, but I never read them. Same with Kath…
  • I recently had the pleasure of reading Maps and Legends by Michael Chabon - a collection of essays on genre fiction. This books includes essays on Sherlock Holmes (in which he argues that ALL fiction is fan fiction), Cormac McCarthy's The Road, the …
  • That’s a very interesting theory, @RichardAbbott
  • When Jacj pointed out that Sandro was supposed to look after the cat, and then later called him ‘Sandro’ instead of ‘Alessandro’ or ‘Sir’ I took it as an acknowledgement that this was the real Jacj. I also see that Sandro‘a life is full of ghosts…